VETS Audience Analysis & Site Strategy

Author: Markus Stobbs
Date: 6-04-02

Introduction

The purpose of this document is to identify the different audiences we serve with the VETS website and develop a strategy for how we will serve their individual and shared needs better with a redesigned site. We will look briefly at current traffic to the VETS website to better understand current usage patterns. We will then look at our goals and mission for the site. Then we will segment our audiences, look at their different needs, and think about how we can serve them better. Finally, we will integrate all this work into several strategies to choose from for how we design and structure our site.

Traffic Analysis

May 2002 traffic shows that 26% of SCD traffic is educational, and probably represents our main audience. Commercial, network and unresolveable domains make up 57% of our traffic, and are impossible to break down by user without an online survey. It's likely that many educational users are also included in this number, surfing from their ISP account rather than from school. Roughly 12% of our traffic is from other countries, 2% from the U.S. Government, while military and non-profits are each under 1%.

Domain
Percentage of Hits
Commercial
26
Educational
26
Unresolved
19
Network
12
Government
2
Canada
2
Japan
1
United Kingdom
1
Australia
1
Germany
1
U.S. Military
1
Non-profit
1
Other Countries
7

The most popular pages in SCD are listed below. I have included Windows to the Universe, UCAR, and NCAR home page stats to provide a sense of the larger context in which our site dwells. Note that we are looking at individual page stats here, not overall site stats. We're trying to get to a sense of the number of visitors to each section of the site. The visits statistic is the closest thing we have to that. It was not available for the VETS site in the Webalizer report, but it seems to be roughly half the number of page views on average.

Visits is calculated by discarding hits to a page from the same IP address within the same 30 minute time period and is therefore not absolutely accurate. In fact, I highly doubt it's relevance for high traffic pages. For instance, the UCAR home page has 1/8th the visits compared to page views rather than the average of 1/2. Windows to the Universe has 1/15th the visits. The weakness of this visits algorithm is that it doesn't accurately account for individuals from institutions that substitute a main gateway or proxy IP address for all outgoing HTTP requests, especially when that institution is large enough that multiple users are likely to be browsing our site at the same time from that location. Therefore for pages with over 10,000 page views a month, I recommend halving page views to come up with a more meaningful estimate.*

Page
May 2002
Page Views
May 2002
Visits
Estimated
Visits*
www.windows.ucar.edu/tour/link/
1,906,764
124,284
900,000
www.ucar.edu/ucar/
50,953
6,438
25,000
www.ncar.ucar.edu/ncar/
17,392
7,080
8,000
www.scd.ucar.edu/
6,561
3,284
 
/nets/
1,648
517
 
/dss/
798
489
 
/news/
787
 
 
/vg/FIRE/ClarkFire.html
635
 
 
/vets/vg/
598
 
 
/vets/vg/ResearchGallery.html
493
 
 
/vets/
454
 
 

Interesting highlights are that the NETS, DSS, and News sections of SCD get more traffic than VETS. The Clark Fire page in VETS is actually more popular than our main page, underlining the importance of getting other sites to link directly to relevant content. However, since that page does not link back to our main site, it is also one of our most popular exit pages. We are not encouraging these visitors to explore our site in more depth.

With only 454 page views for the VETS home page for May, we clearly have some work to do to increase our visibility and traffic.

Traffic Growth Strategies

There are a number of ways we can grow our audiences and traffic:

Site Mission and Goals

What is our mission for the site? What goals do we have in publishing our work and describing what we do? The answers to these questions are critical for guiding the design and content development process, and for creating a site which accomplishes real objectives.

Mission:

Goals:

Audiences

Our intended audiences fall into the following segments:

Audience Segments Interests Platforms
General Public (Adults) Science Education
Cool Visualizations (Wow factor)
PC, Mac
K-6 Students Science Education PC, Mac
K-6 Teachers Science Examples to Show
PC, Mac
7-12 & Undergraduate Students Science Education
Science Examples for Papers
PC, Mac
7-12 & Undergraduate Teachers Science Examples to Show
Lesson Plans
PC, Mac
Graduate Students in Atmospheric Science Data
Software
How to Create Visualizations
UNIX, PC, Mac
Atmospheric Scientists

Data
Software
How to Create Visualizations
Collaboration

UNIX, PC, Mac
UCAR/NCAR Employees Web Engineering Resources
Collaboration
Visualization Development
Group Info (Current Projects, Staff)
Locate Visualizations
UNIX, PC, Mac
Press/Media Obtain visualization media for re-broadcast or publication PC, Mac

We can collapse these into 3 main audiences:

Audience Segments Interests Platforms
Atmospheric Scientists and Graduate Students

Data
Software
Visualizations
Collaboration

UNIX, PC, Mac
UCAR/NCAR Employees

Same as above plus:
Web Engineering Resources
Group Info (Current Projects, Staff)

UNIX, PC, Mac
General Public and Students Science Education
Visualizations
PC, Mac

Based on 26% of our traffic being from .edu addresses, as well as our personal experience with contact from users, we are making the assumption that our primary audience is atmospheric scientists and graduate students. Although we are contacted occasionally by grade 3-12 teachers, our content is fairly complex in its subject matter, and we are much more likely to be a resource for individuals involved in the field of atmospheric research.

UCAR and NCAR employees is broken out as a separate audience even though their needs are similiar to atmospheric scientists and graduate students. This is mainly because we need to account for the unique needs of some employees, such as web engineers who need access to our web engineering resources, employees looking for staff information and current projects, as well as NCAR internal information and resources that will be published on our intranet site, VETS Internal. All of this information will be subsidiary to the offerings to our primary audience on the home page. We hope to use only 10% of our home page real estate for employee-specific information.

We currently have very little educational content for the general public, K-12, and undergraduate students. This is also seen as the mission of the UOP Education & Outreach group, so we will work with them to serve our content to that audience with supplemental educational material as their web plans develop. Our home page will still have some appeal to the general public and students since the visualizations have a wow factor all their own. However, we will not specifically target this audience with science education content.

Strategy

To serve the diverse needs of this many audiences, we will need a home page which provides each audience with a clear path to the content that meets their needs. There are a variety of strategies for accomplishing this.

Home Page Strategy Description Pros Cons
Science Education Education-oriented home page for general public, K-12, and undergraduate students. Meet the needs of scientists and employees with a few links and search capabilities of interest to them. • Targeted toward needs of primary audience
• Expands our outreach
• Home page won't be the primary interface for scientists
• Science ed pieces will require a lot of content development
Scientist Portal Scientist-oriented with data portal, software resources, and visualization search. Meet the needs of general public, students and teachers with a "Students" link. • VETS home page becomes key resource for researchers • General public and education visitors may feel the site is over their head or just for the serious scientist
Audience-specific
(Tell us who you are)
On first visit, home page asks user what audience segment they are, and serves up appropriate home page, setting a cookie to remember selection for future visits. • Each user gets a home page that feels relevant to them
• Users don't have to wade through irrelevant content
• Several home pages requires more development and maintenance effort
• Users who have cookies turned off will be asked the question on each visit
• Users of shared computers may get wrong home page
Intermingled
(new education content)
No audience-orientation, with featured content, including new educational content, and links of interest to all segments. • All users will find some content of interest on home page
• Doesn't necessarily require development of a lot of new content

• Home page doesn't have a clear focus, feels like a catch-all
• Users have to wade through content that is not relevant to them

Intermingled
(fast-launch)
Same as above but with no new education content. We would be serving our existing content (with some additions) through improved interfaces. • Less content development means faster launch • Doesn't really meet the needs of students and the general public who need more education and interpretation to understand our content
Organizational Organize site to reflect the VETS organizational structure. • Matches other NCAR and UCAR sub-sites which present a very organization-oriented picture of themselves

• An organizational view is not as entertaining and informative as a thematic or topical view of content
• Presents a self-absorbed face to the world rather than a service-oriented one

Since we do not currently have educational content and plan to help Education & Outreach rather than develop such content ourselves, the science education and audience-specific strategies are not realistic site strategy options. The audience-specific strategy is more appropriate for the main NCAR site given its larger scope of content for multiple audiences.

We collapsed our audience segments into 3 groups with our primary audience being atmospheric scientists and graduate students. UCAR/NCAR employees have very similiar needs to this group and will require a small amount of real estate on the home page to address their additional unique needs. Since we are not specifically targeting the 3rd group of the general public and students, the scientist portal strategy seems to be the ideal strategy. While the intermingled (fast-launch) strategy is also a possible fit, it doesn't provide the focus and clarity of the scientist portal strategy. We will have a more powerful web presence by devoting ourselves to the needs of our primary audience.